Top Football Cards to Invest in Before Super Bowl LIX 2025

The Super Bowl is not just the pinnacle of the football season; it’s also one of the most exciting moments for football card collectors. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a beginner diving into the hobby, one thing is clear: the value of football cards often skyrockets after the Super Bowl, especially for players who make a lasting impact during the big game.

If you’re wondering why, or which players might see their cards soar in value after Super Bowl LIX in 2025, here’s everything you need to know.

 

Why Do Cards Increase in Value After the Super Bowl?

Legendary Performances Create Demand

Players who dominate the Super Bowl stage—think MVPs, record-setters, or game-changers—often capture the attention of fans and collectors alike. Their standout performances instantly elevate their legacy, which translates to increased demand for their cards.

Global Attention

The Super Bowl isn’t just an American event; it’s a global phenomenon. The game’s massive audience introduces new collectors to the hobby, often driving up prices for key players’ cards as they become household names.

Solidifying a Legacy

A Super Bowl win or MVP can solidify a player’s career and make their cards more desirable long-term. For example, Patrick Mahomes’ rookie cards surged in value after his Super Bowl wins, cementing his place as one of the NFL’s all-time greats.

 

5 Best Football Cards to Buy Before Super Bowl LIX 2025

If you’re looking to invest in cards with high potential for appreciation, here are some top candidates for Super Bowl LIX in 2025:

1. Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs)

2. Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles)

3. Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals)

4. Trevor Lawrence (Jacksonville Jaguars)

5. Rookies Making an Impact

 

1. Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs)

Already a two-time Super Bowl MVP, Mahomes is chasing more championships to build his case as one of the greatest quarterbacks ever. If he leads the Chiefs to victory again, expect his rookie cards (2017 Panini Prizm, Optic, and Select) to see another spike.

2. Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles)

The dual-threat quarterback is looking to secure his first Super Bowl title after falling just short in Super Bowl LVII. A win could cement his legacy, making his rookie cards (2020 Panini Prizm and Donruss Optic) hot commodities.

3. Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals)

Burrow has already proven himself as an elite quarterback. If he captures his first Super Bowl ring, his 2020 rookie cards (Panini Prizm, Mosaic, and National Treasures) could surge dramatically in value.

4. Trevor Lawrence (Jacksonville Jaguars)

The young star continues to impress, and if the Jaguars make a deep playoff run—or win it all—Lawrence’s 2021 rookie cards (Prizm, Select, and Donruss) could gain serious attention from collectors.

5. Rookies Making an Impact

Keep an eye on rookies who might shine on the Super Bowl stage. A breakout performance by a first-year player can catapult their rookie cards (2024 sets) into the spotlight.

 

What Types of Cards See the Biggest Value Jumps?

Rookie Cards

A player’s rookie cards are always the most sought after, especially those from premium sets like Panini Prizm, National Treasures, and Flawless.

Autographed Cards and Patch Cards

Cards featuring autographs or pieces of game-used memorabilia are incredibly popular. These rare, high-end cards often see significant value spikes for players who shine in the Super Bowl.

Graded Cards

Cards that receive a high grade (e.g., PSA 10 or BGS 9.5) are in higher demand, especially for star players. Investing in well-graded rookie cards of potential Super Bowl stars is a smart move.

Tips for New Collectors

Buy Before the Big Game: Player card prices often rise leading up to the Super Bowl. If you have a strong prediction about which team or player will win, it’s wise to buy before the game.

Focus on Rookies: Rookies with breakout performances in the Super Bowl often see the biggest value increases.

Watch for Limited Editions: Low-numbered cards (e.g., /10, /25) and one-of-one cards are the rarest and tend to appreciate the most.

The Super Bowl offers a unique opportunity for football card collectors to watch their investments grow

The Super Bowl offers a unique opportunity for football card collectors to watch their investments grow, especially if you’ve got your eye on the right players. Whether you’re betting on proven stars like Mahomes or rising talents like Trevor Lawrence, there’s no denying that a Super Bowl performance can transform a player’s legacy—and the value of their cards.

As we gear up for Super Bowl LIX, keep these tips in mind, and happy collecting! Who knows? Your next big card purchase could turn into a piece of NFL history.

 

Related Articles

Top 5 Rookie Cards to Watch for a Value Spike in 2025 ->

Top Football Cards to Invest in for 2025 ->

Rookie Cards to Invest in Before NFL Awards Drive Up Their Value ->